The Cabarfeidh Pages (Highland Warriors): Blair worse than Maggie? Learn History or be doomed...

The Cabarfeidh Pages (Highland Warriors)

Viewpoints of a former member of The Queen's Own Highlanders (Seaforth and Camerons)

  • Click here for 1st Battalion The Highlanders/Queen's Own Highlanders website
  • 30 November 2004

    Blair worse than Maggie? Learn History or be doomed...

    Pot in kettle row

    Not many in the media have commented on the enormous hypocrisy  of this:

    The EU's foreign policy chief, Javier Solana, who has been taking part in mediation efforts in Kiev, has described last Sunday's vote as fraudulent, adding that future relations with Ukraine depend on a democratic resolution.

    A non-elected bigwig from the most undemocractic superpower on Earth lecturing other countries about democracy? How about applying some of this to yourself?

    Blithering Bunny

    Blair worse than Maggie shock!

    Now some leftists are intelligent enough to realise than the proposed introduction of ID cards is a bad idea, albeit one that follows logically from the very same leftists' own worldview. Mr Macwhirter (like Muriel Grey) doesn't like ID cards. Good for him (and her). Echoing so many other socialists, Mr Macwhirter is moved to write:

    In five years’ time it may be too late to stop Britain becoming a nastier version of Britain under Margaret Thatcher.

    No surprise there. But then I almost fell off my seat when I got to the next sentence:

    I never thought I’d ever say this, but she was more protective of fundamental rights than Blair. Nearly blown up by the IRA in 1984, she didn’t introduce ID cards or imprisonment without trial.

    No, indeed she didn't. And I would guess that Mrs Thatcher opposes ID cards now. Sure, Mrs T wasn't perfect: she failed to slash the welfare state and gave far too much away to the EU. But she did have a feeling for British liberties and it is rather wonderful to observe that a few of the leftist commentariat are beginning to understand that.

    Freedom and Whisky

    Patriotism and History

    It’s well worth reading a piece by Amanda Craig in the Sunday Times in which she criticises the disjointed teaching of history that is now typical of our schools, public and private. Children are taught a bit about the life of the medieval peasant, before skipping to a module on Hitler’s Germany or life in the trenches in World War One, but not presented with the continuous story of the emergence of their country from the earliest times.

    History should be taught as an effort to encourage patriotism – not turning a blind eye to our faults as a people or past events that were seen as mistakes at the time or look like mistakes now – but offering a complete narrative of how the struggle for liberty took place in this land. It is an inspiring tale that will encourage love of country and a greater willingness to serve the common good and provide mutual support for one another when it is needed.

    Civitas

    To which as a future teacher and a current student of history, I can only add a heartfelt 'Hear hear'. 'He who does not learn the lessons of history is doomed to repeat the past'(Some intelligent bloke said that once!)